Long Island Housing Market Update: October 2026 Prices, Sales & Inventory
Long Island Housing Market Update: October 2026 Prices, Sales & Inventory
Here's something that might surprise you about the Long Island housing market: home prices are still rising, even though fewer homes are selling.
According to the October 2026 OneKey MLS report, Suffolk County's median single-family home sale price reached $733,500, an increase of 4.8% compared with October 2025. At the same time, closed sales declined 8.4%, and the number of homes available for sale increased 5.3%.
So, are we finally seeing the market shift in favor of buyers? Are sellers losing their negotiating power? And what does this mean if you're considering buying or selling a home in Suffolk County?
The answer isn't as simple as looking at one number. Let's break down what's actually happening and what you should be paying attention to as we approach the end of 2026.
October 2026 Suffolk County Market Snapshot
| Market Indicator | October 2026 | Year-over-Year Change |
|---|---|---|
| Median Sale Price | $733,500 | +4.8% |
| Closed Sales | 1,035 | -8.4% |
| New Listings | 1,304 | +3.0% |
| Pending Sales | 927 | -11.1% |
| Homes for Sale | 3,314 | +5.3% |
| Days on Market | 43 | -6.5% |
| Months of Inventory | 3.6 | +5.9% |
| Original Asking Price Received | 100.3% | +0.1 percentage points |
Source: OneKey MLS, Suffolk County Monthly Indicators, October 2026. Single-family residential properties. Data as of November 6, 2026.
1. Suffolk County Home Prices Are Still Climbing
Let's start with the number that gets everyone's attention: home prices.
In October 2026, the median sale price for a single-family home in Suffolk County was $733,500, compared with $700,000 during the same month last year. That's an increase of $33,500, or 4.8%.
Looking at the bigger picture, the year-to-date median sale price reached $730,000, up from $695,000 during the comparable period in 2025.
Those numbers tell us that Suffolk County home values, as measured by median sale prices, have continued to show strength despite slower transaction activity.
However, there's an important distinction homeowners should understand: a higher countywide median sale price does not mean every individual home increased in value by 4.8%.
Median prices can be influenced by the types, sizes, locations, and conditions of homes that happen to sell during a particular month. A three-bedroom ranch in North Babylon, for example, competes in a different segment of the market than a larger waterfront property in Huntington.
That's why I always encourage homeowners to look beyond countywide headlines and examine recent comparable sales in their immediate neighborhood.
2. Fewer Homes Are Selling, but That Doesn't Mean Buyers Have Disappeared
Suffolk County recorded 1,035 closed single-family home sales in October, down from 1,130 in October 2025. That's an 8.4% decline.
Pending sales, which represent properties with accepted contracts, fell even more sharply. There were 927 pending single-family sales compared with 1,043 a year earlier, a decrease of 11.1%.
This matters because pending sales provide an earlier indication of buyer activity than closed sales. A closing generally reflects a transaction that went under contract weeks or months earlier.
The decline suggests that fewer buyers are moving forward with purchases compared with the same period last year. Affordability pressures, financing costs, and the total expense of owning a home may all influence purchasing decisions, although these MLS figures alone do not establish the cause.
But here's the part sellers shouldn't overlook: homes that successfully sold during October still received, on average, 100.3% of their original asking price, before accounting for seller concessions.
That doesn't mean every seller received an offer above asking. It means that, across the properties that closed, the average sale-to-original-list-price ratio remained slightly above 100%.
Buyers are still purchasing homes, and well-positioned properties can still attract strong offers. The challenge for sellers is making sure their home stands out in a market where buyers have more choices.
3. Housing Inventory Is Increasing: What That Means for Buyers
At the end of October, Suffolk County had 3,314 single-family homes available for sale. That's up from 3,146 a year earlier, representing a 5.3% increase.
Meanwhile, new single-family listings increased 3.0% year over year, with 1,304 properties entering the market during October.
More inventory can create opportunities for buyers who have struggled to find a home that meets their needs and budget. It can also increase competition among sellers whose properties appeal to similar buyers.
One of the most useful indicators here is months of supply. Suffolk County had 3.6 months of single-family inventory in October, compared with 3.4 months a year earlier.
Months of supply estimates how long the current inventory would last at the recent pace of pending sales, assuming no additional homes entered the market.
While inventory has increased, 3.6 months of supply does not suggest an oversupplied market. The figures point to somewhat more breathing room for buyers without showing a broad collapse in seller pricing power.
My takeaway: Buyers may have more properties to compare, but sellers who understand their competition and price appropriately can still perform well. The market is becoming more selective, not necessarily less competitive.
4. Are Long Island Homes Taking Longer to Sell?
Interestingly, the October data shows the opposite when compared with last year.
The average time on market for single-family homes that received accepted offers was 43 days, down from 46 days in October 2025.
However, that figure increased from 40 days in September 2026.
So, depending on whether we're comparing month over month or year over year, the story looks slightly different.
It's also important to understand what this statistic measures. OneKey MLS defines days on market until sale as the average number of days between a property's listing date and the acceptance of an offer. It is not the number of days required to complete the closing.
For homeowners preparing to sell, this is another reason not to rely on countywide averages alone. A home's condition, asking price, marketing presentation, location, and available competition can influence how quickly it attracts an acceptable offer.
5. What About Condos and Co-ops in Suffolk County?
Single-family homes receive much of the attention, but the condominium and co-op markets are telling different stories.
| October 2026 | Single-Family | Condo | Co-op |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median Sale Price | $733,500 | $560,000 | $250,000 |
| Annual Price Change | +4.8% | +9.3% | -10.7% |
| Closed Sales | 1,035 | 145 | 36 |
| Months of Supply | 3.6 | 3.0 | 2.9 |
Condominium prices increased 9.3% year over year to $560,000, even though condo closed sales declined 20.3%. Condo inventory rose to 365 available units.
Co-ops moved in a different direction. Their median sale price declined 10.7% to $250,000, while closed sales fell 16.3%. Co-ops also spent an average of 64 days on the market before an accepted offer, compared with 46 days a year earlier.
Because only 36 co-op sales closed in October, monthly median figures for that category should be interpreted with particular care. Changes in the mix of units sold can influence the reported median.
The important lesson is that there isn't one single Long Island housing market. Property type matters, and even within Suffolk County, different market segments can behave differently.
6. Housing Affordability Remains a Major Challenge
One of the more concerning figures in the October report is the Housing Affordability Index.
For Suffolk County single-family homes, the index fell from 83 in October 2025 to 72 in October 2026, a decline of 13.3%.
The index compares median household income with the income required to qualify for a median-priced home under prevailing interest rates. An index of 100 indicates that median income is sufficient under the index's assumptions. A lower figure indicates reduced affordability.
This helps explain why buyers need to consider much more than the asking price when planning a purchase.
On Long Island, a realistic monthly housing budget should account for mortgage principal and interest, property taxes, homeowners insurance, applicable association charges, and expected maintenance expenses.
A home that looks affordable based on its purchase price may feel very different once the full monthly ownership cost is calculated.
Before beginning a serious home search, buyers should work with a qualified lender to understand their financing options and establish a comfortable payment range.
7. What the October Market Means for Long Island Home Sellers
If you're considering selling a home in Suffolk County, the October numbers provide reasons for confidence, along with a few important cautions.
Prices remain elevated compared with last year, and homes that closed in October received an average of slightly more than their original asking prices. At the same time, fewer buyers are entering contracts, and more properties are available for comparison.
That combination makes your initial pricing and marketing strategy especially important.
Three things I'd focus on before listing:
- Price against today's competition. Review recent closed sales, pending transactions, and active listings in your property's specific market segment.
- Make your online presentation count. Professional photography, accurate property details, a compelling description, and a well-planned launch help buyers understand the value of your home.
- Pay attention to early feedback. Showing activity, buyer questions, and competing listings can provide valuable signals about how the market is responding to your asking price.
I've worked with Long Island homeowners long enough to know that the right selling strategy isn't simply about choosing the highest possible asking price. It's about positioning the property to attract qualified buyers and negotiating terms that support the seller's goals.
8. What the October Market Means for Homebuyers
For buyers, October's report offers a mixed picture.
The good news is that inventory has increased compared with last year, creating a somewhat wider selection of available properties. Slower pending sales may also give buyers more opportunities to evaluate homes carefully, depending on the neighborhood and price range.
The challenge is that median prices remain higher than a year ago, while the affordability index has weakened.
My advice is to approach the market with preparation rather than trying to predict the perfect moment to buy.
Understand your financing, compare recent comparable sales, investigate property taxes and condition, and evaluate each home on its own merits. If a property has been on the market longer than comparable homes, find out why before assuming there's an opportunity for a substantial discount.
And remember: a lower asking price doesn't always mean a better deal. The property's condition, financing requirements, potential repairs, and long-term ownership costs all matter.
9. My Outlook as We Head Toward the End of 2026
October's data suggests Suffolk County is experiencing a market where pricing remains resilient, but transaction activity is softer than it was a year ago.
Inventory is gradually expanding, buyers are facing affordability constraints, and sellers can no longer assume that every property will generate the same level of competition.
What I'll be watching in the coming months is whether pending sales stabilize, whether inventory continues increasing, and whether the gap between asking prices and buyer budgets begins to affect closed sale prices more noticeably.
Seasonal changes also matter. The number of new listings and active buyers often shifts as we move into the winter months, so one month's activity should never be treated as a guaranteed prediction of what comes next.
For now, the clearest message is this: Suffolk County's housing market is showing signs of slower activity, but the October data does not establish a broad decline in home prices.
Thinking About Buying or Selling on Long Island?
Countywide statistics are helpful, but your real estate decisions deserve more than a headline. Whether you're selling a home in North Babylon, Deer Park, Bay Shore, Huntington, or another Long Island community, the numbers that matter most are the ones directly affecting your property and price range.
I'm Kenville R. Prince, Real Estate Associate Broker with Weichert, Realtors – Prince & Associates and leader of the Kenville Prince Experience Team. I'd be happy to help you understand your options and develop a strategy that fits your goals.
Let's Get You MovedCall 631-257-1522 or email kenville@listingsoflongisland.com.
Market Data Source: OneKey MLS, October 2026 Monthly Indicators, Suffolk County. Data as of November 6, 2026. Statistics reflect reported MLS activity and may be revised. Single-family figures exclude manufactured housing. Countywide market statistics are not a substitute for an individual property valuation. This article focuses on Suffolk County; Nassau County and Queens County statistics are not included.
Categories
- All Blogs (175)
- Baby Boomers (5)
- Beaches (8)
- Buyer Education (39)
- Central Suffolk Living (2)
- Communities (18)
- Demographics (1)
- Distressed Properties (1)
- Down Payments (4)
- Featured (5)
- First Time Home Buyers (20)
- For Buyers (42)
- For Sellers (34)
- Foreclosures (1)
- Generation X (4)
- Golf (1)
- Holidays (3)
- Holidays on Long Island (1)
- Home Buying Tips (14)
- Home Financing (1)
- Home Improvement (1)
- Home Maintenance (1)
- Home Preparation (2)
- Home Selling Tips (12)
- Home Styles (2)
- Homeownership (5)
- Housing Market Updates (18)
- Housing Trends (1)
- Infographic (4)
- Interest Rates (5)
- Lifestyle (41)
- Local Attractions (24)
- Long Island Housing Market (7)
- Long Island Living (46)
- Long Island Real Estate (49)
- Market Insights (29)
- Move-Up Buyers (19)
- Neighborhood Guide (2)
- New Construction (2)
- North Shore Living (1)
- Outdoor & Recreation (4)
- Pricing (13)
- Real Estate Process (2)
- Relocation Guide (36)
- Rent vs. Buy (6)
- Seasonal Real Estate (2)
- Seller Education (26)
- Selling Myths (9)
- Senior Market (3)
- South Shore Living (5)
- Suffolk County Real Estate (4)
- Things to Do (21)
- Western Suffolk Living (5)
- Western Suffolk Neighborhoods (2)
Recent Posts










R.E. Associate Broker License ID: 10301221652
+1(631) 257-1522 | kenville@listingsoflongisland.com

