NY
Bay Shore
Bay Shore is one of the South Shore’s most dynamic and desirable communities, known for its vibrant downtown, waterfront lifestyle, and convenient location. With access to Fire Island ferries, marinas, restaurants, and shopping, Bay Shore offers a unique mix of coastal living and everyday convenience for buyers seeking lifestyle and value.
Bay Shore Market Insight
- ?Sold Listings
- ?Average Sales Price
- ?Average Days on Market
Recently Sold
$685,000
Single Family Home
$649,999
20 W Belmont ST, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Move right in to this beautifully remodeled mother/daughter home located in the Baywood neighborhood of Bay Shore. On th...
Listed by Century 21 Adams Real Estate
$610,000
Single Family Home
$649,000
47 Community RD, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Beautiful renovated Hi Ranch with gleaming hardwood floors throughout. Updated EIK with open concept. 3 nice sized bedro...
Listed by Sell Fast Realty Corp
$489,000
Single Family Home
$489,000
1022 Fire Island AVE, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Beautiful 3 bedroom, 2 car garage, ranch on a child friendly street. Huge eat-in kitchen and updated 2 bathrooms. Centra...
Listed by Exit Home Key Realty
listing detail
- 6
Bay Shore Senior High School
Public | 9 - 12
- 5
Oak Park Elementary School
Public | KG - 5
- 4
Gardiner Manor School
Public | 3 - 5
- 4
South Country School
Public | 3 - 5
- 3
Hemlock Elementary School
Public | 1 - 5
- 1
Southwest Elementary School
Public | PK - 5
- 0
St Patrick School
Private | PK - 8
- 0
Bay Shore Christian School
Private | PK - 6
- 0
Brook Avenue Elementary School
Public | KG - 2
- 0
Fifth Avenue School
Public | KG - 2
- 0
Mary G Clarkson School
Public | PK - 2
- 0
Woodhull School
Public | PK - 6
- 5
Bay Shore Middle School
Public | 6 - 8
- 4
West Middle School
Public | 6 - 8
- 0
St Patrick School
Private | PK - 8
LIRR Access
Bay Shore Station
Approx. 60 minutes to NYC
Babylon Branch
Major Roadways
Southern State Parkway
Sunrise Highway
Montauk Highway
Local Access
Walkable downtown
Fire Island ferries
Close to marinas & beaches
Lifestyle & Things to Do
Bay Shore’s downtown offers restaurants, cafes, nightlife, and shops, creating a lively and walkable environment for residents and visitors.
Fire Island ferries provide easy access to beaches, making Bay Shore a gateway to one of Long Island’s top coastal destinations.
Marinas, waterfront parks, and the Great South Bay offer boating, fishing, and scenic outdoor recreation year-round.
Community events, festivals, and local attractions create an energetic lifestyle with a strong sense of neighborhood pride.
Homes for Sale in Bay Shore
- 1/50 50
4 Beds 2 Baths 1,808 SqFt$674,888Active42 Greenwood RD #Bay Shore, NY 11706, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Listed by Yes Homes Realty Ltd
Single Family Home
- 1/44 44
2 Beds 4 Baths 1,494 SqFt$680,000Active - 1/8 8
4 Beds 3 Baths 1,662 SqFt$645,000Active
Demographics
Coming Soon
Commute Score
Coming Soon
Coming Soon
Browse Bay Shore Homes
Explore Bay Shore listings including waterfront homes, downtown properties, and investment opportunities.
Browse Homes
Schedule a Consultation
Get expert guidance on buying or selling in Bay Shore with a local market specialist.
Schedule Consultation
Request Market Report
Receive a full breakdown of Bay Shore pricing, trends, and inventory.
Get Market Report
Nearby Communities
Kenville R. Prince
kenville@listingsoflongisland.com